Peer Review Process

Manuscript Acceptance Process

“Research in Sport Management and Motor Behavior” is committed to keeping pace with international publishing standards and is founded on peer review and open access principles. Accordingly, the journal has adopted a double-blind peer-review process, in which neither the authors are informed of the reviewers’ identities nor the reviewers are informed of the identities of the authors. This ensures that manuscripts are evaluated solely on scientific merit and free from prejudice or bias.

Manuscripts submitted through the journal’s online system are sent for peer review if they are consistent with the journal’s scope and meet the journal’s established standards. Following the Editor-in-Chief’s final approval, accepted manuscripts proceed to the publication stage.

“Research in Sport Management and Motor Behavior” is committed to the highest standards of peer review. In accordance with publication ethics, the journal follows the policies and guidelines of the Committee on Publication Ethics (COPE) and complies with the executive regulations of the Law on Prevention and Combating Fraud in Scientific Works. In cases involving potential research or publication misconduct and retraction, the journal follows the relevant COPE regulations.

All submitted manuscripts undergo a double-blind peer-review and evaluation process to ensure the methodological quality and scientific rigor of the research.

After a manuscript is submitted through the journal’s online management system, it is initially reviewed by the journal office, journal expert, and Editor-in-Chief, normally within a maximum of one week. Authors are therefore requested to carefully read the author guidelines and prepare their manuscripts according to the Persian-language instructions before submission.

Following the initial evaluation by the journal’s Executive Manager, manuscripts that receive preliminary approval from the Editor-in-Chief are sent to qualified reviewers for evaluation.

Submitted manuscripts are first screened to ensure compliance with the journal’s formatting and writing requirements and to determine whether their subject matter is consistent with the journal’s aims and scope. At this stage, the author is notified regarding approval of the manuscript for peer review and the requirement to pay the peer-review fee.

Manuscript Acceptance Procedure

  1. Manuscript submission: The manuscript is submitted through the journal website, and an acknowledgment of receipt is sent to the author.
  2. Initial formatting review: The manuscript is checked for compliance with the journal’s formatting requirements and author guidelines.
  3. Editorial assignment: The manuscript is forwarded to the Editor-in-Chief for reviewer selection.
  4. Peer-review fee: A payment request for the peer-review fee is sent to the author.
  5. Peer review: The manuscript is sent to at least 2–3 reviewers.
  6. Receipt of reviewers’ reports: The review outcome falls into one of three categories:
    • A. Rejection
    • B. Acceptance
    • C. Revision required
  7. Communication of reviewers’ comments: The reviewers’ comments and required revisions are sent to the author.
  8. Submission of revisions: The revised manuscript is received from the author.
  9. Comparative review of revisions: The revised manuscript is sent back to the relevant reviewers for evaluation. Three outcomes are possible:
    • A. Revisions not approved: The manuscript is rejected.
    • B. Acceptance: The manuscript is approved.
    • C. Further revisions requested: Additional revisions are requested by the reviewer and the manuscript is returned to the author again.
  10. Final editorial evaluation: Once the revisions are approved, the manuscript is referred to one of the journal’s editorial authorities for final review.
  11. Acceptance fee: Following final approval, a request for payment of the publication/acceptance fee is sent to the author.
  12. Issuance of acceptance letter: After payment is completed, the official acceptance letter is issued and sent to the author or authors by email.